
"Most contemporary
Christians are massively ignorant as to how the church got to where
it is today and of how much current church practice is due simply to
accumulated tradition, with little or no roots in Scripture. This
book provides a useful service in peeling back the layers of
tradition, showing the origins of much that we today call
"church." Christians who want to be biblically faithful,
regardless of their particular tradition or church form, can learn
and benefit from the book."
Howard Snyder, Professor of History and Theology of Mission,
Asbury Theological Seminary, author of "The Problem of
Wineskins" and "The Community of the King."
"PAGAN
CHRISTIANITY is a landmark, a true milestone in the overall
task of bringing in a new style of responsible, interactive
Christianity to replace the old, severely paganized ecclesiastical
forms. Frank has done us a great favor, drawing together revealing
tidbits from hundreds of sources to create a continuous picture of
the formation of today's institutional church. There's nothing like
it in print. It is now THE book on church history from the point of
view of the underground, open church."
James Rutz, author of "Megashift" and "The Open
Church."
"Anyone interested
in the worship of the New Testament church and how that was altered
through the centuries will find Frank Viola's PAGAN
CHRISTIANITY very useful. The authors' position is clear and
quite well documented."
Graydon F. Snyder, Professor of New Testament, Chicago
Theological Seminary, author of "Ante Pacem: Church Life Before
Constantine."
"PAGAN
CHRISTIANITY contains a wide variety of interesting and helpful
historical information of which most Christians - or non-Christians
- will be completely unaware. The book identifies - in part or in
whole - the pagan roots of many of our current church practices, as
well as indicates some borrowed from earlier Jewish or,
occasionally, more recent Customs."
Robert Banks, New Testament scholar, author of "Paul's Idea
of Community" and "The Church Comes Home."
"This feisty book attacks the incipient paganism that has been absorbed into historic Christianity over the years. It exposes the syncretistic weak spots in what we assume to be basic in our way of doing church. Thoroughly iconoclastic, it is also at the same time a good apologetic for the house church movement which has strong restorationist impulses. My guess is that it will anger some readers and thrill others. I am one of the latter. Whatever, it won’t be too easy to dismiss as it is really well researched and substantiated. I think it is definitely worth the read even if I do think it is a tad purist in tone. Just don’t drop it–it is likely to explode."
Alan Hirsch, author of "The Forgotten Ways" and "The Shaping of Things to Come."
"Driving
out demons is easy - compared with changing habits and traditions of
man that develop into idols, to give us what only God should give
us: identity, security, destiny. As in a child, the original
God-given conscience is clean and clear. Many new born Christians
feel the same and have an automatic feel for what is right. But in
the case of organized Evangelicalism in the West, they are swiftly
taken into a religious system that basically believes everything
that Mom and Pap says -- and happily embrace "church
practices" that are not in the Bible. Many just
"know" at some point something is terribly wrong with
Church-as-they-know-it. PAGAN CHRISTIANITY not only substantiates
these ill feelings in millions of Christians with hard facts, but it
provides us with a road map for the journey ahead. Once we know
where we went wrong, repentance and finding the right way forward
comes much easier."
Wolfgang Simpson, author of "Houses That Change the World."
"As a Christian Artist/Musician I've had a chance to experience many different kinds of churches all over the world, from huge cathedral services to bizarre charismatics and strange Third World stuff to stiff denominationals-- and good and bad "house churches". For nearly 35 years in North America, Europe, Africa, the Middle East, and Australia I've been involved with almost every conceivable kind of Christian expression. I've even served on staff as Worship Pastor at a large church here in the U.S. The result? I've already learned from study and experience what Frank Viola and George Barna have proven by historical documentation in PAGAN CHRISTIANITY: The traditional model of how we "do church" is very wrong -- and it's strangling Christ's Body. No matter where you are in your Christian journey, you need to read this book. It's truth whose time has come. Those who have never experienced His tangible presence as a regular occurrence when they meet will find it hard to believe that there is something more than what they know: It's very hard to walk away from what you've invested your life in when you don't know anything else. And the very grace of God Himself can be confusing: He'll fill whatever cup we lift to Him, no matter how small."
Don Francisco, Christian musician/songwriter
"It's a great read and my copy has already been STOLEN by my neighbor who is probably just as fascinated in its contents as I was. PAGAN CHRISTIANITY by house church guru Frank Viola and researcher/author George Barna who have teamed up to give us the most thorough treatment yet of the pagan origins of many of our most cherished Sunday church traditions. Actually, Jim Rutz nailed a few of these in his book "Open Church," but Viola and Barna have gone far beyond Rutz, or anyone I know, in exposing more elements of Protestant church traditions to the scrutiny of historical research. Like dressing up for church. Pulpits and 3 point sermons. Clerical dog collars. Church steeples and seminary training. PAGAN CHRISTIANITY lets George Barna unpack his argument why the new Revolutionaries mentioned in his previous book are not rebelling against God by setting up organic house communities. And it gives Frank Viola the chance to put forward his best thinking yet in a series that has already assisted thousands of people in dealing biblically and historically with accusations of "lack of covering" or "neglecting church" or more recently, of adopting "pagan" practices in starting emerging churches. Ha! Watch as Franky and Georgy turn the tables! Controversial? Yes . . . DUH! . . and the backlash has already started. Frank has responded to questions and objections on his site: www.ptmin.org/answers.htm Anyway, the book is a great read.
Andrew Jones, tallskinnykiwi.com
"Why do we
'do church' the way we do? Most folks seem to assume that our
Christian religious trappings can be traced all the way back to the
first century. But they can't. The things we hold dear-sacred
buildings to meet in, pulpits, sacramental tables, clergy,
liturgies, etc.-were unknown among Paul's assemblies. PAGAN
CHRISTIANITY looks at our major
church traditions and documents when and how they appeared in the
ages long after the apostles. Haven't you ever wondered why people
dress up in their best clothes for the Sunday morning service? PAGAN
CHRISTIANITY unfolds the answer
to this and numerous other questions looming in the back of many
folks' minds. Reading PAGAN
CHRISTIANITY will open your eyes
to the fact that the ecclesiastical emperor really has no clothes
on."
Jon Zens, editor of "Searching
Together"
"In recent years, an increasing number of us pastors have recognized a major blind spot in the living out of our commitment to a Biblical lifestyle. That blind spot is ecclesiology (the doctrine of the church). As a former Presbyterian pastor, I believe PAGAN CHRISTIANITY will play a vital role in shaping the growing conversation on this subject now and in the future. Well researched and well written, this book is accessible to both church leaders and those formerly known as the laity."
John White, former Evangelical Presbyterian pastor; Community Facilitator for LUKE TEN: A Community of Practice for Church Planters http://Lk10.com/
"PAGAN
CHRISTIANITY documents specific areas where contemporary church life
violates Biblical principles. It is painful to read because it
requires taking a journey beyond the comfort zone of our present
paradigms. Whether you agree with all the conclusions the author
draws or not, you will have no argument with his documentation. It
is a scholarly work with an explosive conclusion. Particularly for
those of us in the modern cell church movement, this is a valuable
tool to force rethinking the meaning of the word
"ecclesia." The Holy Spirit is not pleased with
churchianity as we practice it, nor is the watching unchurched
world."
Ralph W. Neighbour, Jr., author of "Where Do We Go From
Here?" and founder of the Cell Church Movement.
"Frank Viola and George Barna have teamed up to create an intelligent, readable, and yet challenging work about the historical roots of the many unbiblical modern church practices that hinder Christian growth in quality and church growth in quantity. Anyone who reads Pagan Christianity with an open mind and heart will never see the church the same way again. May those with newly-gained spiritual eyes not stop there, but go on to do something about it."
Rad Zdero, Ph.D.,
Author of "The Global House Church Movement" and
Editor of "Nexus: The World House Church Movement Reader."
"In
PAGAN CHRISTIANITY, Frank Viola deals with where many of our
'traditions' came from - the order of worship, the sermon, the
church building, the pastor, tithing, etc. - much of it came from
Greek and Roman pagan culture, not from the New Testament. This is a
very radical book. I highly recommend it for the careful reading of
any serious Christian who has a hint that today's church seems to
have strayed from what we see in the New Testament. I pray that
every searching Christian will read Frank's books - they are among
the best."
Nate Krupp, author of "God's Simple Plan for the Church."
"Frank
has done a masterful job both researching and then weaving together
the threads that have made modern church practices what they are -
pagan substitutes for authentic church life. One nice thing about
PAGAN CHRISTIANITY is that it provides the history behind a
perception that many of us Christians share: The way the modern
Western church does things has little to do with the organic life we
see in the New Testament. The difference is so great sometimes that
one wonders how one could possibly have transmuted into the
other."
Hal Miller, author of "Christian Community: Biblical or
Optional?"
"Viola
has done us a great service by tracing the origin of all we
Protestants practice. My one regret is that this book will be only
one out of 100,000 Christian books issued in the year it was
printed. Three hundred years ago-or even two hundred years
ago-PAGAN CHRISTIANITY would have been one of only a few hundred
books . . . and therefore, read by a large portion of Christians.
You can help remedy this by telling all your friends about this
book."
Gene Edwards, author of "A Tale of Three Kings."
"This
book may very well become known as the single most liberating piece
of Christian work penned in the last 1700 years. It will hopefully
become known as the single most influential piece of Christian
literature in this new century. Without doubt it will be loved by
many as it will liberate multitudes and for that same reason it is
sure to be hated and feared by others. Frank Viola has pulled back
the covers to reveal the pagan origins of many if not all of the
practices of this thing we call Christendom. In a very scholarly
fashion he has traced the origins of the traditions practices and
institutions of all that which makeup what we call Christianity
today. In contrast he boldly illustrates the simplicity and almost
tribal nature of the 1st century church the bride of Christ as she
met with her groom in irresistible freedom, life and love."
Michael Warriner, book reviewer.
"Taking up
topics like these with a title like PAGAN CHRISTIANITY would lead
one to expect a lot of fire-breathing and biased finger-pointing,
but not so. Even if lots of cherished
tradition and conventional wisdom get shredded by Viola's
unrelenting assault with historical facts, the arguments unfold with
an encouraging lack of arrogance. This book contains so much history
(both anecdotal and analytical), that it is impossible to find a
soft spot to attack. An objective person must address the issues
raised, even if they hurt. Protestantism, Evangelicalism and
Neo-Pentecostalism all get their fair share of blows, not Roman
Catholicism only. The author does not
hide his personal leanings toward informal, idealistic models of
Christian community, but he isn't "preachy" about it. No
Denomination's faithful get demonized, even though the practices of
every Denomination imaginable get blasted by the books' copiously
footnoted accounts of how they came to be (As detective Friday would
say, "just the facts, Ma'am"). Bottom lines: Highly
valuable perspective. I have no reason to doubt any of the ample
sources cited in this adequately-researched volume. Well-written;
not boring. The authors' conclusions are logical and transparent
enough. Provides plenty of raw material as well as food for thought
to anyone wondering how Sunday morning in Christendom ever became as
predictable and lifeless as it is."
Charles Wilhelm, author of "Biblical Dyslexia."
"This
is an important book which demonstrates that many of the practical
aspects of contemporary church life, ministry and structure have
little or no biblical basis and are, in fact, inspired by a wide
variety of non Christian patterns and ideas most of which are
inimical to Christian life and growth. Many readers will find this
book challenging in the extreme but all who are concerned with the
future of the church should read it."
Dave Norrington, Lecturer of religious studies at Blackpool and the Fylde College, author of "To Preach or Not to
Preach" |